Cost of living in Shelter Island, NY

Shelter Island is a census-designated place in Suffolk County, NY. ACS 2024 5-year population is 2,125. Rent uses Suffolk County ACS 2024 5-year median gross rent; Shelter Island is too small for ACS housing. HUD FMR not bundled. Median home value is $1,025,400. Median household income is $165,734. Insurance is the NAIC state average; food is a USDA plan — no town indexes.